The name "finger sandwiches" conjures up spongy bread and flavorless vegetables in my mind. However, with a little effort, these can be stellar hors d'oeuvres for your next garden party.
Cucumber Tea Sandwiches
A good cucumber sandwich should highlight the fresh flavor, and that's where salting the cucumber in advance comes in. Chive and lemon butter make for a sophisticated alternative to cream cheese.
Cucumber Tea Sandwiches
Salt the cucumber before it goes anywhere near the bread, then blot both sides until the slices stop leaving wet circles on a towel. That small pause matters more than making every finger exactly the same width. Soft chive butter gives the cucumber something to stick to and protects the white bread without burying its clean crunch under cream cheese. I’d cut these close to serving, because the exposed edges dry faster than an uncut sandwich even when the middle is properly protected. A thin, overlapping layer is enough; a double stack of cucumber makes the fingers slide apart as soon as somebody picks one up.
Ingredients
Method
- Slice cucumber into 1/16-inch rounds, toss with salt in a colander and stand for 15 minutes. Spread on clean towels and blot thoroughly on both sides.
- Beat butter with chives, lemon zest and white pepper until spreadable. Lay out the bread and spread one face of every slice evenly with the butter.
- Arrange cucumber over eight buttered slices in one thin overlapping layer, trimming stray edges rather than folding them into thick spots. Close with the other eight slices, buttered faces inward.
- Put the sandwiches in a covered container and refrigerate for 15 minutes to firm the butter slightly. Keep the bread flat without weighting it heavily.
- Trim the crusts with a sharp serrated knife and cut each sandwich into three equal fingers, wiping the knife between cuts. Serve 24 fingers, two per serving, or refrigerate covered until serving the same day.
Egg Salad Finger Sandwiches
Egg salad is one of the world's great sandwich fillings, and it works great on a tea sandwich too. Using crème fraîche instead of mayo adds a little garden party flair.
Don't lose these recipes! Drop your email and we'll send them to you, so you've got them handy the next time you're planning dinner.
Egg Salad Finger Sandwiches
Steam the eggs, cool them completely, and chop them finely enough that a narrow finger holds together when you cut across it. Crème fraîche binds this salad with a little mustard, while dill supplies the green flecks without the hard crunch of celery. Soft rye gives the pale filling a useful contrast and doesn’t need to be toasted. Don’t add more dressing just because the bowl looks less creamy than a deli tub; the eggs soften the mixture as it chills, and an overfilled finger is difficult to eat neatly.
Ingredients
Method
- Bring 1 inch of water to a boil in a saucepan fitted with a steamer basket. Add eggs, cover and steam for 13 minutes, then move immediately to ice water for 10 minutes.
- Peel the cooled eggs and chop into small pieces with a knife. Fold in crème fraîche, Dijon, dill, lemon juice, salt and pepper without beating the eggs smooth.
- Cover and refrigerate the salad for 20 minutes. Spread a thin layer of softened butter over one face of all 16 bread slices.
- Divide the salad equally among eight buttered slices and spread into a level layer almost to the edges. Close with the remaining bread, buttered faces inward.
- Trim crusts with a sharp serrated knife and cut each sandwich into three fingers. Keep the 24 pieces refrigerated in a covered container; allow two fingers per serving and use within 24 hours.
Chicken Salad Tea Sandwiches
In the tea sandwich context, I want a chicken salad that emphasizes crunch and green and sweet flavors alongside the chicken and creamy dressing. Celery, of course, but grapes and almonds add a new twist.
Chicken Salad Tea Sandwiches
For a tray that’ll sit beside cucumber and egg sandwiches, I like chicken salad with a little sweetness and a definite crunch. Roast the breast yourself, then cut it into small pieces after chilling instead of pulling it into long strings that catch on the knife. Finely diced grapes and toasted almonds go through the filling rather than sitting in separate lumps at the edges. The sour cream dressing stays fairly lean, so stop mixing as soon as it coats the chicken. These triangles need a level filling all the way to the corners; a mound in the middle leaves half the party eating mostly bread.
Ingredients
Method
- Heat oven to 400°F. Rub chicken with oil, 1/4 teaspoon salt and pepper, then roast in a small baking dish for 22 to 28 minutes until the thickest part reaches 165°F.
- Toast almonds on a small pan in the same oven for 4 to 6 minutes, watching closely. Rest chicken for 5 minutes, cut into small pieces and transfer to a shallow container; refrigerate promptly for 40 minutes until cold.
- Crush the cooled almonds lightly. Stir sour cream, mayonnaise, Dijon and remaining salt together, then fold in the cold chicken, grapes, celery and almonds.
- Butter one face of each bread slice. Spread the salad equally over six slices in a flat layer reaching the edges, then close with the other six slices, buttered faces inward.
- Trim crusts and cut each sandwich diagonally in both directions to make four small triangles. Keep the 24 triangles covered and refrigerated; serve two per portion within 24 hours.
Spinach Artichoke Pinwheels
Revealing my hayseed origins: the first time I had spinach and artichoke dip, it seemed incredibly urbane. The pinwheel provides a far better delivery mechanism than a cracker, too.
Spinach Artichoke Pinwheels
Squeeze both vegetables dry before mixing, or the tortillas will turn gummy while they chill. Parmesan and lemon give these cold spinach-artichoke rounds the flavor of the familiar dip, but a thin, tightly rolled filling is what gives you a clean spiral instead of a loose white lump.
Ingredients
Method
- Squeeze thawed spinach in a clean kitchen towel until very dry. Chop artichokes finely, spread over paper towels and press firmly to remove surface moisture.
- Beat cream cheese, Parmesan, lemon juice, zest, garlic powder and pepper together in a bowl. Fold in spinach and artichokes, breaking up dense spinach clumps.
- Spread one-quarter of the filling evenly over each tortilla, leaving only a 1/2-inch bare strip along the far edge. Roll snugly toward that strip without crushing the filling out.
- Wrap each roll tightly and refrigerate for at least 60 minutes until firm. Keep the rolls horizontal so the filling remains evenly distributed.
- Trim just enough from each end to expose a full spiral, then cut each roll into eight equal rounds with a sharp knife, cleaning the blade between cuts. Yield 32 pinwheels, two per serving; refrigerate covered and use within 24 hours.
Taco Pinwheels
Taco pinwheels are a cold sandwich that suits game day perhaps more than the garden party. Be careful with the technique, though; it's easy for this to turn into a mess, but some careful drying and chilling help immeasurably.
Taco Pinwheels
Cook the beef until the pan is almost dry before turning it into a cold filling; leftover taco juices are exactly what make a tortilla soft and gummy by the time a party starts. Mashed pinto beans help the seasoned meat cling to the cream cheese, so each cut round holds together without a toothpick. A small amount of finely diced red pepper adds crunch without the water you’d get from fresh tomatoes or salsa. Chill the beef before mixing, then chill the rolled tortillas again before cutting. That two-stage cooling is useful work, because warm beef melts the binder and makes the whole spiral slump.
Ingredients
Method
- Heat oil in a skillet over medium heat and soften onion for 3 minutes. Add beef and cook for 6 to 8 minutes, breaking it into fine crumbs, until it reaches 160°F.
- Stir in cumin, chili powder, salt and water and cook for 2 minutes until the liquid evaporates. Spread beef in a shallow container and refrigerate promptly for 30 minutes until cold.
- Beat mashed pinto beans and cream cheese together. Fold in cold beef, cheddar and dry red pepper until evenly combined.
- Spread one-quarter of the filling over each tortilla, leaving a 1/2-inch strip bare at the far edge. Roll firmly toward that edge, wrap tightly and refrigerate for 60 minutes.
- Trim the uneven ends lightly and slice each roll into eight equal rounds, wiping the blade often. Serve 32 pinwheels, two per portion, and keep refrigerated in covered containers until serving.
Mini Croissant Sandwiches with Mortadella
Croissants are pretty delicate, so finding a filling that complements the texture can be a challenge. Mortadella and fontina are both soft enough to ensure sandwich integrity as you bite.
Mini Croissant Sandwiches with Mortadella
Choose croissants about two and a half inches long, small enough to finish without a knife. Mortadella folds neatly inside, and thin Fontina won’t shatter the pastry when you bite through it. Blend the roasted pepper into the mayonnaise instead of adding slippery strips. Assemble these close to serving, while the pastry still has its delicate edge.
Ingredients
Method
- Pulse the dried roasted peppers, mayonnaise, balsamic and pepper in a small processor until smooth. Scrape into a bowl and refrigerate while preparing the bread.
- Split each mini croissant horizontally without crushing its top. Divide mortadella and Fontina into 24 equal portions.
- Spread the pepper mayonnaise thinly over the cut faces. Put a few dry arugula leaves on each bottom and fold one portion of mortadella over the leaves.
- Add one portion of Fontina and close each croissant gently. Keep the filling within the edges so the sandwiches can be picked up easily.
- Arrange in a single layer in a covered shallow container and refrigerate until serving, preferably within 4 hours. Yield 24 whole mini sandwiches, two per serving.
Ham and Cheese Party Rolls
Some of the best sandwiches are delicious at any temperature. While these are technically rolls, they seem to be sandwiches in spirit, and whatever you call them, they're amazing.
Ham and Cheese Party Rolls
These are soft baked bread spirals with ham and Gruyère tucked through the dough, so the filling stays with the roll instead of falling out of a sliced bun. Roll each dough rectangle evenly before spreading the mustard, and leave one clean edge so the seam has somewhere to stick. Don’t pack the pieces into a small casserole dish; a little room on two sheet pans lets their sides cook through while the centers stay soft. I’d put these out warm in a separate batch from the cold tea sandwiches. They’re more substantial than a cucumber finger, which is useful when the party stretches across lunchtime.
Ingredients
Method
- Stir warm milk, yeast and sugar in a large bowl. Add 4 cups flour, salt, egg and butter and mix into a shaggy dough; knead for 8 to 10 minutes until smooth and elastic, using the extra flour only as needed to prevent sticking.
- Cover and let rise in a warm spot for 60 to 75 minutes until doubled. Line two rimmed sheet pans with parchment and divide the dough in half.
- Roll each half into a 12-by-10-inch rectangle. Spread each with 1 tablespoon Dijon, leaving a 1/2-inch strip bare along one long edge, then scatter half the ham and cheese evenly over each.
- Roll each rectangle from the opposite long edge into a 12-inch log and pinch the seam closed. Cut each log into 12 equal 1-inch slices and place cut side up on the pans, spaced about 1 inch apart.
- Cover loosely and let rise for 25 to 35 minutes until puffy. Heat oven to 350°F during this second rise.
- Bake for 25 to 30 minutes, switching pan positions halfway through, until golden, the bread centers reach about 190°F and the ham filling reaches at least 165°F. Cool on the pans for 10 minutes before serving.
- Serve 24 filled party rolls, two per portion. Refrigerate leftovers promptly in a covered container and reheat covered at 325°F until the filling reaches 165°F.
Smoked Salmon Tea Sandwiches
With a smoked salmon sandwich, you really want to do everything to highlight the fish. A dill-butter spread and soft rye bread make for a simple means of directing focus towards that tasty, tasty salmon.
Smoked Salmon Tea Sandwiches
Cold-smoked salmon already brings enough salt and richness that a thin layer of lemon-dill butter is all it needs on soft rye. Lay the slices flat rather than folding them into high ruffles, because narrow tea fingers cut much more cleanly through one even fish layer. The butter should be soft enough to spread without tearing the bread but not shiny and melting at the edges. Chill the closed sandwiches briefly before trimming, then keep them covered so the exposed salmon stays moist. There’s no reason to crowd these with cucumber and onion when those fillings already have plenty of room elsewhere on a party tray.
Ingredients
Method
- Beat butter with dill, lemon zest, lemon juice and pepper until smooth and spreadable. Keep the salmon refrigerated while preparing the bread.
- Spread one face of every rye slice with a thin even layer of flavored butter, taking it to the corners.
- Divide salmon equally among eight slices, laying the fish in a flat layer and trimming overhangs to fill any gaps. Close with the remaining slices, buttered sides inward.
- Cover and refrigerate the sandwiches for 15 minutes to firm the butter slightly. Trim crusts with a sharp serrated knife without pressing down hard.
- Cut each sandwich into three equal fingers for 24 pieces. Serve two per portion and keep covered in the refrigerator until serving the same day.
Pimento Cheese Finger Sandwiches
There's no reason why pimento cheese has to just be cheddar. Playing with different cheeses is recommended, and I think a smoked cheese like Gouda works great here.
Pimento Cheese Finger Sandwiches
Grate both cheeses finely so the pimento spread cuts neatly inside a narrow sandwich instead of dragging long shreds across the knife. White cheddar does most of the work, while a smaller amount of smoked Gouda gives the filling a savory edge without turning it into a smoky dip. Drain the pimentos until they look matte rather than glossy with jar liquid. There’s no cream cheese in this version, so let the grated cheeses sit briefly at room temperature before folding them into the mayonnaise. Keep the finished layer modest; the point of a tea finger is to eat the whole thing comfortably in a couple of bites.
Ingredients
Method
- Let grated cheddar and Gouda stand at room temperature for 10 minutes while draining and blotting the pimentos. Chop any large pimento pieces smaller.
- Stir mayonnaise, Dijon, cayenne and black pepper together in a bowl. Fold in both cheeses and the pimentos until evenly coated, without processing the mixture smooth.
- Divide the spread among eight bread slices and smooth it into an even layer to the corners. Close with the remaining bread and press only lightly.
- Cover and refrigerate for 15 minutes to firm the filling. Trim crusts with a sharp serrated knife, wiping the blade whenever cheese builds up on it.
- Cut each sandwich into three equal fingers for 24 pieces. Serve two per portion and keep covered and refrigerated until serving, using within 24 hours.
Ribbon Sandwiches
For the social media show-offs among you, you found your cold sandwich. With three layers- carrot, beet, and parsley- feel free to swap out the veggies for your preferred color palette for your event.
Ribbon Sandwiches
Ribbon sandwiches earn their place through the cut edge, so keep the filling layers thin and the bread slices aligned before chilling. Beet, carrot, and parsley make three separate colors without food dye, and a little cream cheese gives each vegetable layer enough body to stay put. This is a good one to build ahead because the layers need time to settle before you cut them. Don’t skip drying the cooked vegetables; a wet beet puree can stain halfway through the bread overnight and turn a clean stripe into a pink blur.
Ingredients
Method
- Steam carrot slices over boiling water for 10 to 12 minutes until very soft. Mash, spread on a plate to release steam and cool for 10 minutes; blot away any visible moisture.
- Divide cream cheese into three equal portions. Process one portion with the beet, 1/2 teaspoon lemon juice and a pinch from the measured salt until smooth, then scrape into a bowl.
- Clean the processor and blend a second portion with the cooled carrot, remaining lemon juice and another pinch of salt. Clean again and blend the last portion with parsley, remaining salt and black pepper.
- Build four identical stacks, each using a white slice, one-quarter of the beet filling, a wheat slice, one-quarter of the carrot filling, a white slice, one-quarter of the parsley filling and a final wheat slice. Spread each filling evenly to the corners.
- Wrap the four stacks snugly and refrigerate for at least 60 minutes. Keep them flat without a heavy weight, which would squeeze the colored fillings out.
- Trim the crusts with a sharp serrated knife. Cut each stack into three equal strips, then halve each strip crosswise to make six small rectangles; yield 24 ribbon sandwiches, two per serving.
- Keep covered and refrigerated until serving within 24 hours, separating layers in the container with parchment so the cut faces stay clean.
Mini BLT Sandwiches
A can make a BLT into a finger sandwich with one simple trick. Blending the bacon into the mayo ensures all the flavor, with no risk of bacon shattering across your lap.
Mini BLT Sandwiches
Chop the cooked bacon into the mayonnaise and every little BLT gets its share without a long strip pulling the sandwich apart. Cocktail pumpernickel is already the right size, so there’s no pile of trimmed bread to deal with after assembly. Use small plum tomatoes and blot the slices well; one tomato round should sit comfortably inside each sandwich instead of hanging over the sides. The lettuce needs to be dry enough that the bacon spread actually grips it. Assemble these fairly close to serving, when the bacon still has a little crispness and the small bread squares haven’t absorbed the tomato juices.
Ingredients
Method
- Heat oven to 400°F. Lay bacon on a rimmed sheet pan and bake for 15 to 20 minutes until crisp, then drain on paper towels and cool for 10 minutes.
- Cut tomatoes into 24 thin usable rounds, reserving the rounded ends for another use. Lay rounds on paper towels and blot their top surfaces.
- Chop the cooled bacon finely and mix with mayonnaise, Dijon and pepper. Cut or tear romaine into 24 small pieces that fit the bread.
- Spread the bacon mayonnaise thinly over one face of all 48 bread squares. Put a lettuce piece and one tomato round on 24 squares.
- Close with the remaining bread, spread sides inward, to make 24 complete mini BLTs. Refrigerate covered until serving within 4 hours; allow two sandwiches per portion.
Tomato Tea Sandwiches
Tomato sandwiches are tough as they turn soggy quickly. However, by salting the tomatoes and letting them drain, much of the problem is solved, and a basil butter provides a protective layer as well.
Tomato Tea Sandwiches
Good tomatoes don’t need a thick cheese spread to become a tea sandwich, but they do need enough time on a towel to stop dripping before you close the bread. Basil butter supplies a thin protective layer and keeps the filling tasting of tomato rather than mayonnaise. Use ripe tomatoes that still cut into clean slices, not soft ones that collapse when you lift them from the board. A serrated knife should do the cutting work while your other hand only steadies the bread; pressing down hard is how you squeeze the juice into the crumb and flatten the whole sandwich.
Ingredients
Method
- Slice tomatoes about 1/8 inch thick and lay on a tray lined with paper towels. Sprinkle with salt, stand for 10 minutes and blot both sides thoroughly.
- Beat butter with basil, sherry vinegar and pepper until evenly mixed. Spread a thin layer over one face of all 12 bread slices.
- Cover six buttered slices with one even layer of tomatoes, trimming pieces to fill gaps without building a thick stack. Close with the remaining bread, buttered faces inward.
- Cover and refrigerate for 10 minutes to firm the butter. Trim crusts carefully with a serrated knife without pressing the tomatoes into the bread.
- Cut each sandwich diagonally in both directions to make 24 small triangles. Serve two per portion, keeping the tray covered and refrigerated until serving the same day.
Turkey Cranberry Mini Sandwiches
Turkey sandwiches take on a twist here. The homemade cranberry and orange relish is good enough that it might become a regular with your roasts and at the breakfast table.
Turkey Cranberry Mini Sandwiches
Fresh cranberry-orange relish gives these little rolls a sharper bite than a layer of canned sauce, but drain it after the sugar has drawn out the juice so it doesn’t soak into the bread. Thin smoked turkey and a modest swipe of cream cheese are enough filling for a two-inch rye roll, especially once the lettuce is tucked inside. I’d make the relish a day ahead and assemble the sandwiches on party day, when the rolls are still soft and the contrast between cold turkey and tart fruit is at its best.
Ingredients
Method
- Pulse cranberries and orange in a processor until finely chopped but still textured. Stir in sugar and refrigerate for 30 minutes, then drain in a fine sieve for 5 minutes without pressing into a puree.
- Split the mini rye rolls horizontally. Spread cream cheese evenly over their cut faces, using a thin layer rather than a thick mound.
- Divide the turkey into 24 equal portions. Tuck one dry lettuce leaf into each bottom and fold one portion of turkey over it.
- Divide the drained relish over the turkey in a shallow layer and close the rolls. Wipe away any filling that spills beyond the bread.
- Yield 24 whole mini sandwiches, two per serving. Refrigerate in a covered shallow container and serve within 8 hours of assembly.
Cream Cheese and Olive Tea Sandwiches
Olive spread is a rather fun retro recipe that deserves an update. Kalamata olives bring this into the 21st Century, but feel free to play around with Niçoise olives or any other higher-quality variety.
Cream Cheese and Olive Tea Sandwiches
Chop the olives by hand and press them dry; a wet processor puree makes this filling loose and gray. Green olives, Kalamata and lemon zest give the cream cheese plenty of bite without extra salt, and a short chill makes the sourdough triangles easier to trim.
Ingredients
Method
- Chop both kinds of olives finely by hand. Spread over paper towels and press with another towel to remove excess brine.
- Beat cream cheese and sour cream together until smooth. Fold in olives, lemon zest and black pepper, keeping the small olive pieces visible.
- Divide the filling equally among six bread slices and spread evenly to the corners. Close with the remaining six slices and press lightly.
- Cover and refrigerate for 15 minutes. Trim crusts with a sharp serrated knife, wiping the blade clean between sandwiches.
- Cut each sandwich diagonally in both directions to make 24 small triangles. Serve two per portion and keep covered and refrigerated until serving within 24 hours.
Strawberry Tea Sandwiches
I've personally never been a fan of sweet sandwiches, but the mascarpone instead of the usual whipped cream does a lot here. Be sure to use the absolute best strawberries you can afford.
Strawberry Tea Sandwiches
Keep the strawberries unsugared so they stay in clean slices instead of releasing a bowlful of syrup before the sandwiches are built. The mascarpone gets the small amount of sweetness, along with vanilla, and goes on both sides of the bread to hold the fruit in place. These belong at the sweeter end of a tea tray, but they still eat like a sandwich rather than a slab of cake. Use soft bread with a fine crumb and cut with a light hand. This is one filling I wouldn’t assemble the night before, because fresh berry slices gradually soften the bread even when you’ve blotted them carefully.
Ingredients
Method
- Slice strawberries lengthwise about 1/8 inch thick. Lay the slices on paper towels and blot their surfaces gently without crushing the fruit.
- Stir mascarpone with powdered sugar and vanilla just until smooth. Avoid prolonged beating, which can make the cheese grainy.
- Spread the mascarpone mixture evenly over one face of every bread slice. Cover six slices with a single overlapping layer of strawberries, trimming pieces to fill gaps.
- Close with the remaining bread, spread sides inward. Trim crusts with a sharp serrated knife and cut each sandwich diagonally in both directions.
- Yield 24 small triangles, two per serving. Cover and refrigerate promptly, then serve within 4 hours so the berry layers and bread stay distinct.
Shrimp Tea Sandwiches
When cooking shrimp, you want to give it just the barest cook-through. Chill in advance to prevent soggy bread.
Shrimp Tea Sandwiches
Steam the shrimp just until opaque, then cool them before chopping so the filling stays juicy without carrying warm cooking liquid into the dressing. A fine mince makes sense in a tea finger; large curved shrimp are awkward to cut through and tend to pull the bread apart. Horseradish and dill give the crème fraîche enough character that you don’t need a heavy mayonnaise dressing or a pile of celery. Spread the mixture in a level layer and keep the finished sandwiches cold, because their small size makes it easy to forget that the filling still needs the same care as a bowl of seafood salad.
Ingredients
Method
- Bring 1 inch of water to a boil under a steamer basket. Add shrimp, cover and steam for 4 to 6 minutes, turning once, until opaque and the thickest shrimp reach 145°F.
- Spread shrimp in a shallow container, cool for 5 minutes and refrigerate promptly for 30 minutes until cold. Blot away any collected liquid and chop the shrimp very finely.
- Stir crème fraîche, horseradish, dill, lemon juice, salt and pepper together. Fold in chopped cold shrimp until lightly bound.
- Butter one face of every bread slice. Divide shrimp filling evenly among eight slices, spread to the corners and close with the remaining bread, buttered faces inward.
- Trim crusts and cut each sandwich into three fingers to make 24 pieces. Serve two per portion, keeping covered and refrigerated until serving the same day.
Asparagus Tea Sandwiches
Be sure to make these only at the height of asparagus season; otherwise, you're likely to come out with a stringy, flavorless mess. Construction is also essential here, as you need to build on a grid, but a little advance planning deserves serious rewards, because nothing's better than fresh asparagus at its peak.
Asparagus Tea Sandwiches
Choose pencil-thin asparagus so the stalks are tender enough to bite cleanly inside a small finger, and cool them completely before they touch the bread. Lining the spears up in the direction of the final cuts gives every piece two short stalks rather than a tangle that falls out when you lift it. A thin Asiago cream-cheese spread holds them in place, but the real trick is drying the cooked asparagus carefully, especially around the tips where water likes to hide.
Ingredients
Method
- Trim asparagus to 3 1/2-inch lengths measured from the tips, reserving the lower tender portions for another meal. Steam the tips over boiling water for 3 to 4 minutes until tender but still green.
- Transfer asparagus to ice water for 2 minutes, then drain and spread on clean towels. Blot very thoroughly, including between the tips, and let stand for 5 minutes.
- Beat cream cheese with Asiago, lemon zest and pepper. Spread one face of all 16 bread slices with a thin even layer.
- Arrange six asparagus tips on each of eight slices in three evenly spaced pairs, all pointing in the same direction. Close with the other slices, spread sides inward, and refrigerate covered for 10 minutes.
- Trim crusts without cutting through the asparagus tips. Cut each sandwich lengthwise into three fingers between the pairs, leaving two spears inside every finger; yield 24 pieces, two per serving.
- Keep the sandwiches covered and refrigerated and serve the same day, lifting them with a small spatula so the fillings stay aligned.
Watercress Tea Sandwiches
It's hard not to feel like you should be wearing a floral sundress and a floppy hat when you eat a watercress sandwich; even, and perhaps especially, if you're a six-foot-tall dude with a beard. However, watercress, with its peppery undertones, is a seriously underutilized ingredient.
Watercress Tea Sandwiches
Watercress has enough peppery bite to carry a sandwich without egg salad underneath it, especially when the leaves are chopped into softened butter with finely ground toasted walnuts. Dry the greens well before chopping, since wet leaves make the butter difficult to spread evenly. Soft milk bread keeps the little triangles tender and lets the filling stay the main flavor. I’d keep the walnut pieces fine rather than chunky, because a large hard piece can tear a delicate triangle apart right where you want the cut edge to look neat.
Ingredients
Method
- Heat oven to 350°F. Toast walnuts on a small sheet pan for 6 to 8 minutes until fragrant, then cool for 10 minutes and pulse into fine crumbs without making nut butter.
- Chop the dry watercress finely. Beat softened butter with salt and pepper, then fold in the greens and walnut crumbs until evenly distributed.
- Spread the mixture evenly over one face of all 12 bread slices, working gently so the soft crumb doesn’t tear. Pair the slices with their filled faces inward to make six sandwiches.
- Cover and refrigerate for 10 minutes to firm the butter slightly. Trim crusts with a serrated knife and cut each sandwich diagonally in both directions.
- Yield 24 small triangles, two per serving. Keep covered and refrigerated until serving within 24 hours; let the portion being served stand for about 5 minutes so the butter loses its refrigerator hardness.
