Get Your Hands Dirty: A True Maryland Crab Feast at The Stony Creek
“I feel like I’m in little Santa’s Workshop—I’m making crab for Suzie!” That’s Guy Fieri, elbows-deep in a pile of steamed blue crabs, surrounded by locals teaching him the fine art of Maryland crab picking. Twenty minutes south of Baltimore, at a place called The Stony Creek near Chesapeake Bay, Guy discovered what a real crab feast looks like—and it’s nothing like the polite seafood dinners you might be imagining.
A Family Tradition Rooted in Chesapeake Bay
Bill Green and his wife Mary opened The Stony Creek eight years ago, but their connection to seafood runs much deeper. The couple worked the Open Air Market together when they were kids, and Bill learned to steam crabs from his father—who’s still doing it Dad’s way. Mary even sports a female blue crab tattoo, proving this family’s obsession with Chesapeake crustaceans is the real deal.
The restaurant serves everything crab: jumbo lump crab meat, half crab toast, a crab pretzel, crab balls, and of course, steamed crabs by the basket. It’s the kind of place where the Outrageous Cuban Fricase de Pollo might seem out of place—here, it’s all about one ingredient done a dozen different ways.
Don't lose this list! Drop your email and we'll send it to you, so you've got it handy next time you're hungry or planning a trip.
The Steaming Secret: No Old Bay in Sight
Here’s where things got interesting. When Bill revealed his seasoning blend, Guy had to pause: “Everybody stop for a moment—no Old Bay on the steam crabs?” Bill’s custom mixture includes kosher salt, paprika, dry mustard, chili flake, cayenne, and thyme—all kept fresh. As the steam rises, it carries these seasonings into every crevice and joint of the shell, and it coats your fingers as you pick.
The crabs get layered into the steamer with generous dustings of seasoning between each layer, topped with fresh corn, then steamed for 25 minutes. The result? Guy called them “very rich, buttery, sweet—the salt compliments it really well. The seasoning on the crab is pretty outstanding.”
Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes: “Not a Bread Cake”
The crab cakes here follow a strict philosophy. Bill builds his sauce with heavy mayonnaise, prepared mustard, a little lemon juice, and liquid egg as the binder. A touch of baking powder gives them lift and helps thicken the mixture. Then comes six pounds of jumbo lump crab meat—pure lump, no claw meat mixed in.
When it came to the breading, Bill added just regular white bread crumbs and stopped Guy cold: “Wait wait wait—that’s it?” Bill’s response: “You just want enough to hold it together as a binder. This is a crab cake, not a bread cake.” Each six-ounce cake bakes at 350 degrees for seven to ten minutes.
Guy’s verdict after his first bite: “I can’t even begin to see any filler. Super fresh. I’m not getting over citrus, I’m not getting over mustard, I’m not getting over mayo—tasting the crab. Everybody’s working together to enhance that jumbo lump.”
Tips from The Stony Creek’s Crab Masters
Layer your crabs with seasoning: Don’t just season the top—build layers of crabs and spices so steam carries flavor throughout.
Skip the knife: Some people cut crabs in half, but the locals here just crush them with their hands. “That’s a waste of time,” one regular explained.
Try them naked: While butter is traditional and vinegar with horseradish is popular, many regulars prefer their crabs plain to taste the sweet meat.
Similar to how the Italian Kale Slaw with Chef Mark Stark keeps ingredients minimal to let quality shine, this crab feast proves that when your product is this good, less is more.
As Mary put it: “Once you try it, whether you’re from Maryland or not, you’re hooked. You’re absolutely hooked.” Find The Stony Creek and other Triple D favorites in our restaurant directory.