A Three-Pound Breakfast That’ll Make You Proud
“Do you have a scale?” Guy Fieri asked, staring down at the massive plate in front of him at Charlie Parker’s Diner in Springfield, Illinois. The answer? Just the food alone weighs three pounds. Welcome to the home of the Horseshoe Sandwich.
This Quonset hut—one of those big silver Army buildings from the 1940s and 50s—has lived many lives. It was an airplane hangar in World War II, then a town hall, then a plumbing shop. Now it’s cranking out some of the biggest plates Guy has ever encountered, and he’s absolutely here for it.
The Origin Story of the Shoe
The Horseshoe was invented right here in Springfield back in the 1920s. The original version featured two pieces of toast topped with ham cut in a horseshoe shape, covered in cheese sauce, with french fries piled on top as “the nails in the Horseshoe.” Some folks claim the first shoe was actually made with hamburgers, but these days Charlie Parker’s will make it with just about anything.
Don't lose this list! Drop your email and we'll send it to you, so you've got it handy next time you're hungry or planning a trip.
Owner Brenda Shirley and her husband had zero restaurant experience when they took over. They’d eaten there before, and her husband said “I think we can do better than this.” Brenda agreed, and they bought the place with nothing but a dream and a love of cooking. Now they’re cranking out 3,500 breakfast shoes a year in over 1,000 different variations.
How They Build These Beasts
The breakfast shoe starts with two pieces of toast as the foundation. Then comes the chaos: scrambled or over-easy eggs, bacon, sausage patties, hash browns—whatever combination the customer dreams up. You can even go half cheese sauce, half gravy. One customer ordered wheat toast with their shoe, which Brenda joked “makes them healthy.”
The secret weapon is Brenda’s homemade cheese sauce, made from her mother’s recipe. They start by making a roux with flour, keeping it moving constantly—”or you’ll ruin it.” Then milk goes in, a little at first, followed by cheese until it’s nice and creamy. There’s a special seasoning that gives it what Guy described as “a little bitey” quality. When he tasted it, his verdict was clear: “That’s good though, that’s what people really dig.”
Similar to the bold flavors found in dishes like Lemonade Pork He Calls “Flavor City” 🤤, the Horseshoe doesn’t hold back on seasoning.
The Ultimate Custom Creation
Guy wasn’t satisfied with a regular shoe—he wanted to make something special. His creation started with a 16-inch pancake (yes, 18 ounces of batter), then added a ham steak, a burger patty, three scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, and all three types of potatoes they had. They needed a pizza peel to move it and served it on a pizza tray.
“I don’t think bread by itself really says enough,” Guy said. “I don’t think it says I love you.”
When asked how he’d finish, Guy was confident: “That should at least cover you till lunch.” Two hours later? He was still working on it.
Tips From the Kitchen
If you’re attempting cheese sauce at home, the transcript reveals some crucial technique: add milk gradually to your roux, keep stirring constantly, and don’t rush the process or you’ll wreck it. The key to their sauce is that special seasoning that gives it a bit of heat—something to consider if your homemade cheese sauce tastes flat.
Everything’s big at Charlie Parker’s—from the Slim Jim (a hot ham and cheese) to the stuffed pork chops to the German rouladen (steak rolled with garlic, onions, and bacon from Brenda’s mom’s recipe). Much like the comfort food tradition at Real Deal Soul Food in Savannah, GA, this is home cooking scaled up to legendary proportions.
Looking for more Triple D spots? Check out our restaurant directory to find your next destination.