Paul’s Live From New York

If you’re looking for standout Pizza in Eureka, California, Paul’s Live From New York is a must-visit — and Guy Fieri agrees, having featured it on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.

The restaurant was featured in Season 19, Episode 2 — an episode called “All Things NY” that first aired in 2014. In fact, Guy Fieri liked it enough to come back — the restaurant appeared in 2 total episodes, including Season 23 (“Extra Helpings”).

With a solid 4.2-star Google rating and more than 975 reviews, it’s clear that Paul’s Live From New York delivers a dining experience worth talking about. The menu is moderately priced, making it accessible for a casual meal or a special outing.

You’ll find Paul’s Live From New York at 604 F St, Eureka, CA 95501, and you can call ahead at +1 707-442-5800. The restaurant is open seven days a week. Check out their website for the latest menu and hours before you go.

A spot on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives isn’t just a TV appearance — it’s a badge of honor. Guy Fieri’s team scouts thousands of restaurants before selecting the ones that make the cut, and Paul’s Live From New York made the list. The show has helped introduce countless food lovers to the best under-the-radar restaurants in America, and Paul’s Live From New York is a standout example.

If you’re planning a trip through Eureka, California and looking for a restaurant that delivers on both flavor and atmosphere, put Paul’s Live From New York at the top of your list.