Pizza Restaurants in Ohio

When Guy Fieri rolled his red Camaro into the Buckeye State between 2009 and 2010, he uncovered some serious pizza gems that have kept Clevelanders coming back for more. Ohio’s pizza scene, as featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, showcases the kind of authentic, no-frills establishments that have earned devoted followings for decades.

Cleveland emerged as the undisputed pizza capital of Guy’s Ohio adventures, with both featured restaurants calling this city home. Leading the pack is Sterle’s Slovenian Country House, boasting an impressive 4.6-star rating and serving up pies with Eastern European flair that you won’t find anywhere else. Close behind is Geraci’s Restaurant at 4.4 stars, a neighborhood institution that’s been slinging dough and winning hearts for generations.

With an average rating of 4.5 stars across both establishments—and both still proudly serving customers today—these Triple D-approved pizza joints prove that Ohio knows a thing or two about crafting the perfect slice. Whether you’re craving classic flavors or something uniquely Cleveland, these spots deliver the goods.