Sandwich Restaurants in New York
When Guy Fieri rolls into New York in search of the perfect sandwich, he finds a city that takes its bread and fillings seriously. From 2011 to 2020, the Mayor of Flavortown discovered 9 outstanding sandwich spots across the Empire State, with 8 still serving up their legendary creations today. These joints have earned an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars from hungry diners who know good eats when they taste them.
The journey spans from the bustling streets of Manhattan and Brooklyn to hidden gems in Syracuse and Williston Park. Among the standouts, Defonte’s Sandwich Shop in Brooklyn leads the pack with a stellar 4.7-star rating, serving up old-school Italian sandwiches that have stood the test of time. Don Antonio by Starita brings Neapolitan flair to the sandwich scene with a well-deserved 4.6 stars. Whether you’re craving classic deli-style stacks or innovative flavor combinations, these Triple D-approved destinations prove that New York’s sandwich game is absolutely on point.
Defonte’s Sandwich Shop
Still Open
Brooklyn, New York City, New York
Don Antonio by Starita
Still Open
New York, New York
Don Antonio By Starita
Still Open
Manhattan, New York City, New York
Ben’s Best Deli
Still Open
Queens, New York City, New York
Black Tree
Permanently Closed
Manhattan, New York City, New York
Hildebrandt’s
Still Open
Williston Park, New York
Jimmy’s Diner
Still Open
Brooklyn, New York City, New York
Byblos Mediterranean Cafe
Still Open
Syracuse, New York