Pizza Restaurants in New York

When Guy Fieri’s iconic red Camaro rolled through the streets of New York between 2010 and 2020, he uncovered some seriously flavorful pizza joints that earned their place in Triple D history. From the bustling boroughs to unexpected neighborhoods, these three featured pizzerias showcase the Empire State’s diverse approach to America’s favorite pie.

Leading the pack is Don Antonio by Starita, a standout destination boasting an impressive 4.6-star rating that had Guy reaching for slice after slice. This spot brings authentic Neapolitan traditions to hungry New Yorkers, proving why it caught the attention of the Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives crew. Meanwhile, Pizza Junction in North Tonawanda offers a different vibe, serving up hometown flavors that keep locals coming back.

With an average rating of 4.1 stars across the featured locations and two of the three restaurants still serving up pies today, these New York pizzerias represent some of the best discoveries from Guy’s cross-country adventures. Whether you’re craving classic New York-style or something more adventurous, these Triple D-approved spots deliver the goods.