Italian Restaurants in New York

When Guy Fieri rolls into New York in his red Camaro, Italian cuisine takes center stage in some of the most memorable episodes of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. Between 2010 and 2020, the show spotlighted six outstanding Italian eateries across the Empire State, and remarkably, all six remain open today—a testament to their enduring quality and devoted followings.

From the streets of Manhattan to the neighborhoods of Syracuse and Williston Park, these restaurants have earned an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Leading the pack is Mulberry Café in Lackawanna, boasting a stellar 4.7-star rating, where Guy discovered dishes worthy of his signature “Winner, winner, chicken dinner!” Don Antonio by Starita, with locations earning 4.6 stars, showcases authentic Neapolitan pizza that left even the Mayor of Flavortown speechless.

Whether you’re craving handmade pasta, wood-fired pizza, or classic red sauce dishes, these Guy-approved spots deliver the kind of bold, authentic Italian flavors that have made them Triple D legends. Ready to take a trip to Flavortown? These New York Italian gems are waiting.