Italian Restaurants in Massachusetts

When Guy Fieri rolled into Massachusetts with his signature Camaro, he discovered a treasure trove of authentic Italian cuisine that would make any nonna proud. Between 2010 and 2020, the Mayor of Flavortown featured three outstanding Italian establishments in the Bay State, and remarkably, all three are still serving up delicious plates today. With an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars, these restaurants have proven that their Triple D appearances were well-deserved.

East Boston emerged as the undisputed heart of Massachusetts Italian cooking on the show, claiming two of the three featured spots. Leading the pack is Casa Razdora in Boston, earning top honors with a stellar 4.7-star rating for their handcrafted pasta. Close behind are East Boston favorites Italian Express Pizzeria and Rino’s Place, both holding strong at 4.6 stars. These neighborhood gems showcase the kind of old-school Italian-American cooking that Guy lives for—generous portions, family recipes passed down through generations, and flavors that transport you straight to the old country. Whether you’re craving fresh pasta or perfectly charred pizza, these Triple D-approved spots deliver the real deal.