When Smoke Meets Melt: The Butcher Shop’s Brisket Masterpiece
“This is a cross between a barbecue sandwich and a french dip,” Guy Fieri declared, breaking down exactly what makes the Brisket Melt at The Butcher Shop something special. It’s the kind of dish that defies easy categorization—and that’s precisely the point.
The Butcher Shop is a father-son operation that combines a full-blown butcher shop with a restaurant and beer garden. As Guy put it, “As soon as you walk into the door, you’re already in a great mood before you even tasted the food.” But once you do taste the food? That’s where things get serious.
Building the Brisket From Scratch
This isn’t your standard smoked brisket. The process starts with what Guy called “a gigantic brisket”—a monster of a cut that gets rubbed down with an impressive spice blend. We’re talking brown sugar, white sugar, salt, paprika, black pepper, celery seed, pink salt (to keep that color), garlic powder, onion powder, chili powder, and cayenne pepper. After an overnight rest, the brisket goes into the smoker for a full 16 hours, then finishes in the oven for another hour and a half.
Don't lose this list! Drop your email and we'll send it to you, so you've got it handy next time you're hungry or planning a trip.
The result? Brisket that pulls apart beautifully with what Guy described as “really good smoke on that.” But here’s what sets this sandwich apart: the brisket is pulled, not sliced or chopped. As Guy noted, “The brisket, which you don’t find in this style very often—it’s either sliced or chopped. This gives it a ton of texture.”
The House-Made Barbecue Sauce
Nothing about this dish is phoned in. The barbecue sauce is made in-house with tomato paste, tamarind paste, apple cider vinegar, molasses, brown sugar, dried mustard, salt, cayenne pepper, celery seed, and pineapple juice. That combination simmers for 35 minutes until everything melds together. Similar to how restaurants featured in dishes like a Meatloaf Sandwich build their flavors from scratch, The Butcher Shop takes no shortcuts.
Assembling the Melt
The sandwich comes together on Texas toast that’s been hit with butter, garlic, and parmesan. The pulled brisket gets loaded up with two pieces of cheese and finished with the braising liquid—that “jus” that carries all those concentrated flavors. Caramelized onions add sweetness that plays against the smoke and salt.
Guy’s reaction was enthusiastic: “Love the smoke, but not too much smoke to where you say this is only a barbecue sandwich.” He appreciated the balance—sweetness, smokiness, saltiness all working together. And when a customer at the table chimed in about being “a big cheese guy” who loves caramelized onions, the verdict was clear: “They’ve hit all my points.”
Tips From The Butcher Shop Kitchen
Don’t skip the overnight rest: That spice rub needs time to penetrate the meat before it hits the smoker.
Low and slow, then finish hot: The 16-hour smoke followed by oven finishing creates that perfect texture—tender enough to pull but with enough structure to hold up in a sandwich.
Make your own sauce: The tamarind and pineapple juice add complexity you won’t find in store-bought options. Like the bold flavors in a “BIG Flavor” Meatball Sub in Montana, it’s the homemade touches that elevate a dish.
Guy also sampled the brisket pierogies during his visit, calling them “the best pierogi ever.” His final take on The Butcher Shop? “You’re as detailed and decorated as a Christmas tree.”
Looking for more Triple D spots to visit? Check out our restaurant directory to find your next destination.