Bucatini Carbonara: Guy Fieri’s Guide to the Real Deal
“Carbonara is one of those dishes that I think has been screwed up so many times,” Guy Fieri declares at the start of this cooking segment, and he’s on a mission to set the record straight. This isn’t your heavy cream-laden, pea-studded version you might find at a chain restaurant — this is traditional Italian carbonara the way the Fieri family makes it.
What Actually Goes Into Real Carbonara
Guy breaks it down simply: pancetta, egg yolks, a little parsley, and great pasta. That’s it. “When you start seeing peas in it, when you start seeing heavy cream added to it, you’re not really having carbonara,” he explains. The star of the show is pancetta — Italian bacon that’s cured but not smoked, giving it a saltier, less smoky flavor than American bacon.
The pasta choice matters too. Guy reaches for bucatini, which he describes as “spaghetti with a hole in the middle.” He emphasizes spending money on quality dried pasta, pointing out its dry, almost handmade texture. The reason? Properly dried pasta takes longer to cook and has that perfect bite — what Italians call al dente.
Don't lose this list! Drop your email and we'll send it to you, so you've got it handy next time you're hungry or planning a trip.
The Technique That Makes or Breaks It
Guy’s methodical approach reveals why so many home cooks mess this up. He starts the pancetta in a pan over medium to low heat. “If we get this too hot too fast, we’re not going to render that fat out,” he warns. That rendered fat becomes essential to the dish.
The water situation gets its own lecture. Guy drops some knowledge: one gallon of water to one tablespoon of salt. “This is where we miss it so often,” he says, mimicking home cooks who barely season their pasta water.
Here’s the critical move that separates the pros from the amateurs: once the pancetta gets beautifully crispy, Guy pulls it out with a slotted spoon and reserves the fat. Only then do the onions go in. Why the extra step? “You shortcut this, you put those onions in with that pancetta right now, you’re gonna sog up that pancetta,” he explains. All that moisture from the onions would ruin the crispiness.
Quality Ingredients, No Shortcuts
Guy gets passionate about sourcing. For eggs, he recommends organic with golden orange yolks. For cheese, it’s Parmigiano-Reggiano from Parma, Italy — “the bomb,” as he calls it, recounting a trip where he and Hunter actually made Parmesan cheese in Italy. Even Smokey the dog makes an appearance, lurking hopefully near the pancetta.
The Fieri philosophy comes through clearly: “Really good eggs, really good Parmesan cheese, really good bucatini, really good pancetta — do it the right way and you’re going to have a rock star dish.”
Guy also shares a story about cookbook authenticity, recalling someone who complained that chef recipes didn’t work. The problem? They added all the ingredients without following the steps. Each step exists for a reason — like rendering fat before adding onions, or waiting for the sauce to be completely ready before dropping pasta. As Guy puts it, “Pasta waits for no one.”
This segment proves that sometimes the simplest dishes require the most discipline. Much like Spicy Pork Bulgogi or a Sloppy Jacques, the magic is in respecting the technique.
Looking for more Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives spots to visit? Check out our restaurant directory to find Triple D locations near you.