Saved stops

Italian Restaurants in Manhattan, New York City, New York – Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives

Italian Restaurants in Manhattan, New York City

When Guy Fieri rolled into Manhattan on the hunt for authentic Italian flavor, he discovered two neighborhood gems that prove New York City’s Italian culinary tradition is alive and well. Both restaurants featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives remain open and thriving, earning an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars from devoted fans.

Leading the pack is Don Antonio By Starita, a Neapolitan pizza powerhouse pulling in a stellar 4.6-star rating with its wood-fired pies and traditional Italian technique. Close behind is John’s of 12th Street, a beloved East Village institution rated 4.4 stars that continues to serve up classic Italian-American comfort food in its historic candlelit dining room. From hand-stretched dough to generations-old recipes, these Manhattan spots deliver the kind of bold, authentic flavors that earned Guy’s signature “Winner, winner, chicken parm dinner” approval.

Don Antonio By Starita

Don Antonio By Starita

Still Open

Manhattan, New York City, New York

★★★★☆ 4.6
Episode 235: Keepin' It Real
ItalianPizzaSandwich
John’s of 12th Street

John’s of 12th Street

Still Open

Manhattan, New York City, New York

★★★★☆ 4.4
Episode 160: Global Traditions
ItalianVegan/Vegetarian