If the words flaky crust, buttery crumble, and silky filling set your heart racing, consider this your official road map. These restaurants—featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives—turn out memorable pies alongside the comfort-food plates that first caught the show’s eye. From the desert Southwest to the Chesapeake Bay, here’s where to slice into the good stuff.
1. Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits — Chicago, IL

In true Midwestern fashion, this Logan Square bakery-café keeps things simple: house-made crust, seasonal fillings, and warm hospitality (plus biscuits if you need something savory). The ever-changing pie board means you might encounter anything from tart fruit medleys to chocolate-laden crowd-pleasers, but the attention to old-school technique never wavers—exactly what landed the shop on Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives.
2. Pie-O-Neer — Pie Town, NM

Perched along Highway 60 with little else around but a wide-open sky, Pie-O-Neer is a pilgrimage point for crust connoisseurs. The kitchen leads into mexico/" class="ddd-auto-link">New Mexico flavors—think subtle chile heat mingling with fruit or custard—while keeping the crust impossibly tender. Guy Fieri’s visit introduced viewers to Pie Town’s humble baking traditions, proving that great pie can be the main attraction.
Don't lose this list! Drop your email and we'll send it to you, so you've got it handy next time you're hungry or planning a trip.
3. Rock Springs Café — Black Canyon City, AZ

This 1918 roadside café lures Phoenix-to-Flagstaff travelers with country cooking, but its expansive pie case hooks them for life. More than a dozen varieties cycle through daily—fruit, nut, cream, you name it—each baked in a super-flaky crust that stands up to the desert heat. Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives highlighted the café’s century-old baking heritage, making it a must-stop on any I-17 road trip.
4. Harry’s Roadhouse — Santa Fe, NM

Part eclectic diner, part neighborhood hangout, Harry’s Roadhouse pairs green-chile comfort food with an always-rotating roster of pies. Expect classic flavors next to creative specials that pull from local ingredients. The episode showcased Harry’s laid-back vibe, earth-toned décor, and scratch baking—ideal for travelers who like a little art with their dessert.
5. Blue Bonnet Cafe — Marble Falls, TX

A Hill Country institution since 1929, Blue Bonnet Cafe dishes out chicken-fried steaks and all-day breakfasts, yet regulars know the real showstopper waits in the pie fridge. Mile-high meringues, cream-filled classics, and fruit versions that taste like summer earned the café a spot on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives—and a permanent place in many Texans’ travel itineraries.
6. Texan Cafe & Pie Shop — Hutto, TX

Don’t let the modest storefront fool you—this Williamson County café turns out some of the state’s most beloved pies. The kitchen sticks to time-honored recipes, rolling dough by hand and baking in small batches. When Triple D dropped in, the sheer variety (often 20-plus pies) proved that serious baking cred can hide in the most unassuming places.
7. Dangerously Delicious Pies — Baltimore, MD

Housed in a former rock-and-roll bar, this Charm City spot dishes sweet and savory pies with equal swagger. The crust is buttery yet sturdy enough to cradle everything from gooey chocolate fillings to stick-to-your-ribs meat pies. Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives viewers loved the punk-rock energy—proof that pie doesn’t always have to feel old-fashioned.
8. Proper Pie Co. — Richmond, VA

Founded by a New Zealand expatriate, Proper Pie brings Kiwi-style hand pies—savory and sweet—to Virginia’s capital. Flaky, all-butter pastry encases inventive fillings that rotate with the seasons. The bakery’s efficient open kitchen and global flair caught Triple D’s eye, while its portable pies make perfect road-trip fuel for East Coast pie hounds.
