Italian Restaurants in Wyoming

When Guy Fieri rolls his red Camaro into the Cowboy State, he’s not just hunting for steaks and bison burgers—he’s uncovering Wyoming’s surprisingly vibrant Italian food scene. From 2014 to 2023, Triple D has spotlighted three authentic Italian gems scattered across this rugged Western landscape, and locals have taken notice with an impressive average rating of 4.4 stars.

In the shadow of the Bighorn Mountains, Pie Zanos in Buffalo serves up Italian classics that have earned devoted fans and a coveted 4.4-star rating. Down in Laramie, the Crowbar & Grill matches that stellar score while putting its own Wyoming spin on Italian-American favorites. And nestled in the tourist haven of Jackson, Pinky G’s Pizzeria keeps hungry skiers and adventurers fueled with pies that score a solid 4.3 stars.

These aren’t your typical red-sauce joints—they’re frontier outposts where passionate chefs prove that authentic Italian flavors thrive even in America’s least populated state. Whether you’re passing through Buffalo, exploring Laramie, or hitting the slopes near Jackson, Guy’s Italian discoveries prove Wyoming is full of flavorful surprises.