Sandwich Restaurants in Indiana

When Guy Fieri rolled into Indiana’s capital city, he discovered that Indianapolis knows how to stack a serious sandwich. From 2011 to 2025, the spiky-haired host has featured three Hoosier State sandwich spots on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, and the results speak for themselves with an impressive 4.5-star average rating across the board.

Leading the pack is Subito, a Indianapolis gem boasting a stellar 4.9-star rating that had Guy reaching for seconds. Then there’s Indy’s Historic Steer-In Restaurant, a 4.5-star classic that proves sometimes the old-school joints do it best. The 3 Sisters Café rounds out the Triple D sandwich tour with its own devoted following. While one of these beloved spots has since closed its doors, two remain open and ready to deliver the kind of flavor-packed, out-of-bounds sandwiches that earned them a spot on Guy’s culinary road trip. Whether you’re craving towering deli stacks or creative flavor combinations, Indianapolis delivers sandwich excellence that’s earned the Fieri stamp of approval.