Pizza Restaurants in Hawaii

When Guy Fieri brought his red Camaro to the Hawaiian islands, he discovered that paradise serves up more than just tropical sunsets—it dishes out some seriously flavorful pizza. Between 2016 and 2021, Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives featured 4 pizza spots across Hawaii, with 3 still serving up slices today. These island pizzerias have earned an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars, proving that Hawaiian pizza passion goes far beyond pineapple toppings.

From the volcanic shores of Hilo to the sun-soaked streets of Maui, Guy found pizza perfection in unexpected places. Cafe Pesto in Hilo wowed with its creative combinations, while Maui Brick Oven in Kihei delivered that authentic wood-fired flavor that had Guy reaching for slice after slice. Over in Wailea, Matteo’s Osteria brought Italian tradition to tropical terrain. Kihei emerged as the pizza capital of the islands, claiming two of the four featured spots. Whether you’re catching waves or chasing sunsets, these Triple D-approved pizzerias prove that Hawaii’s culinary scene extends well beyond the luau.